2017 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"I like Carmenère so when i saw that the Society were offering an Exhibition level Carmenère I bought six bottles. The first of these, drunk a fortnight ago, was everything i'd hoped for: rich fruit with just the right level of acidity for balance making it a harmonious and very pleasurable drinking experience. However when we opened the second bottle this evening we were in for a real disappointment; not that the wine was corked, it wasn't. But it was thin and acidic : and wherever was the fruit? I know you can get some variation between one bottle and the next but this was beyond a joke."
Mr Michael J Webber (01-Aug-2020)
"Black berried fruit with juicy acidity and a cedary edge. Lovely."
Mr Colin Hewson (19-Jul-2020)
"One of my go to wines- smooth, moorish and surprisingly good with curry and spicy foods- or is that just my bizarre taste buds?"
Mr Timothy H McAdam (24-Apr-2020)
"Nasty chemical taste, not at all what I expect from this kind of wine. Really tasted as if some chemical from cleaning processes contaminated the wine. So unpleasant that I poured the wine down the drain. "
Dr Peter Richardson (06-Feb-2020)
"This is a very polished wine – not oaky, but still very smooth. 3.5 stars, if I could do that. It’s not especially complex in flavour – a French wine drinker would miss the terroir – but it’s very easy to enjoy. We had it with a lasagne, but I imagine it would be fine without food too."
Professor Stephen Babbage (06-Jan-2020)
"Oh dear. Not to my taste at all. Flat, insipid, dull, uninspiring. Sometimes one one ventures into new territory to be hugely disappointed, A grape that I will avoid in future"
Mr Anthony J Kinahan (11-Dec-2019)
"Dry and full bodied. Cigar, cedar, cinnamon and dark chocolate hues. Hints of blackberry and juniper. "
Mr Terence Witzmann (30-Oct-2019)
"This is a big, smooth, characterful wine. Shoot me down if you like, but it seems to have everything I long for, but rarely experience in Bordeaux. You cannot go wrong at this price. This is the kind of wine I joined the society to access."
Mr Christopher Winter (07-Jul-2019)
2016 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"Smooth, woody, plums, spicy finish"
Mr Matthew Utting (22-Jul-2020)
"Colour: Rich dark cherry with a ruby rim.
Aroma: Med-intensity, herbaceous and peppery, tobacco, ripe black forest fruits and plums.
Taste: Full, bold and unctuous yet feels mellow with fine-grained well-integrated tannin. Smooth chocolate and strong coffee fuelled palate, moderate smoky finish.
Overall: Very green/vegetal with the fruit playing only a secondary role. Big, round and harmonious but all in such an understated way as it comes across as soft, savoury and well-structured. Good value and certainly recommend."
Mr Gabriel Higgins (10-Nov-2019)
"I have to disagree with the relatively poor reviews of this wine. I really liked it. Lovely dark colour and tasting of black cherries and cloves with a hint of sweetness it went perfectly with Iberico pork. It even handled a starter with a little chilli. I think the 2025 drink by date is probably pushing it given the quite low tannins already present. It still has low acidity which means its very smooth and perfectly aged right now (late 2018). For the price a real bargain."
Mr Richard Hadfield (17-Sep-2018)
"I bough two bottles of this wine. The first I opened in early summer and was very disappointed with the quality. I left it a couple of months and last night opened the second bottle, left it to stand for a couple of hours and ate it with Spag Bol. The nose was disappointing, a bit rough to be honest, and I'm sorry to say the flavour was the same. If it was a fiver I would maybe have said oh well worth a try, but to sell as an Exhibition wine at £12 is way off the mark.
I think the Society has got it wrong with this one, it certainly should not have the exhibition label on the bottle."
Mr Colin Dartnell (11-Sep-2018)
"Opened the Exhibition Carminere yesterday as I’ll be out Thursday. I’m writing this Wednesday but post Thursday.
It’s a deep red, throws a few legs down the glass, clearly a big and young wine. The nose has a chemical edge which I don’t like but it very much background to the plum/damson and chocolate.
Simple plum and damson palette, but there’s the typical variety greenness peeking in. Finish is hot. It’s a bit young for now and needs food. Will this age and improve, probably no more that a couple of years.
For me the greeness stays with you for so long that it’s off putting. A well made wine which may have great appeal but not a rebuy for me.
This is my review from the community tasting event on the society's forum. Many more views over there. Link at top of this page.
"
Mr Russell Sainty (08-May-2018)
Mr Richard Simon (06-May-2018)
2016 VINTAGE - PRESS REVIEWS
Rotherham Advertiser (16th Jun 2019)
"… has intense
flavours of black fruit with some black pepper. - David Clay"
Knackered Mothers Wine Club (11th Apr 2018)
"The Exhibition range
from The Wine Society is full of reasonably priced gems like this one. This is
made from the Carmenère grape grown in a cool spot in Chile’s Colchagua Valley.
It’s made by the Undurraga family (a big name in Chilean winemaking) but under
their new project, Koyle. Big, bold and juicy with bright, bramble fruits, one
glass of this and suddenly that mountain of holiday washing didn’t seem quite
so bad. - Helen McGinn"