2018 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"Very smooth and balanced with vanilla and caramel. Was expecting a little more blackcurrant fruit although there was a some plum and cherry. "
Dr Andre Gilburn (05-Dec-2020)
"I really liked this wine! Fruity on the palate, quite a lot of tannin but a fruity finish and very smooth, enjoyable and well worth the pennies. Went very well with entrecote mexicaine. Shame it's out of stock now or I'd be ordering a case, lovely."
Mr Chris Thorpe (28-Nov-2020)
"Quite nice, pleasant."
Mr James Bowkett (06-Nov-2020)
"Definitely tannin rich and alcohol rich but backed up with rich black currant flavours. Best decanted and left for an hour. "
Mr Rory Bremner (01-Nov-2020)
"I am not a Cab Sauv expert but this wine is a very good buy . Lots of depth and flavour. Rather too alcoholic , though, which takes away from the balance. A bottle could last two days."
Dr John Cruickshank (12-Oct-2020)
"Cracking wine at a cracking price. Lets hope future vintages are as good and its a consistent quality. Well done !"
Mr Richard Burton (10-Oct-2020)
"It's very drinkable and certainly punches well above its price. I'd have scored higher, mainly for VFM, if it had been enjoyable soon after the bottle was opened. It was rather disappointing on the nose and to drink, rather characterless. However, the CabSav much better a day later when its fruit came through more enjoyably."
Prof Tom Watson (08-Oct-2020)
"terrible tannins....left it in the bottle for 3 hours and still heavy on tannins.......should come with a "Must Decant" warning! And certainly did not go with the cheddar cheese as recommended in matching food to this wine."
Mr Arvind Chandna (27-Sep-2020)
"Massive wine that sometimes, depending on your palette that day, requires a bit of chewing through. The W/S blurb credit a "blackcurrant perfume", but in my eyes it's like licking the spoon that's been dipped in blackcurrant jam - far more intense in flavour. Towards the end there's a deep alcoholic oak/wood taste ( I don't own anything made of cedar!), which is either magnificent or "wow, that's huge". Bang for buck is amazing."
Mr Dafydd Griffith (08-Sep-2020)
"Quite easy to drink a whole one on your own by mistake. Dark and juicy. "
Mr Edward Bogira (07-Aug-2020)
"I absolutely love this wine, such a strong and wonderful taste - back to order a case this time! "
Mr Matthew Gilson (06-Aug-2020)
"Good grief, what a stunning bargain. Cracking Cabernet at this price point that screams blackcurrant, but restraint is there as well. The tannins are an absolute joy to behold. Seriously good winemaking and can't believe its price. Ordered a few to sample, but will be ordering a case. Chile is most definitely 'growing up'. "
Mr Simon Godfrey (19-Jul-2020)
"OUCH!
Why has no one mentioned that this wine is so tannic that it needs considerable aeration and/or decantation. I gave it an hour and a half of both before I found it mildly agreeable. We all have different preferences and this is not a wine I will reorder.
"
Mr Charles Yoe (12-Jul-2020)
"Was a huge fan of the 2013 vintage, less so the 2015, but this is as good, if not better, than the 2013. As the WS note says 'the best vintage of this wine we have ever bought'... that'll do for me. In my humble opinion the best value for money bottle in the UK market bar none... if you like full-bodied, harmonised with oaked, red wine. "
Mr Paul Allison (07-Jun-2020)
"Very drinkable, full of black current flavour ...much better than previous vintages and excellent value at this price. Looking forward to lockdown summer BBQ's with this easy cab sav."
Mr William A Cross (14-May-2020)
2018 VINTAGE - PRESS REVIEWS
joannasimon.com (24th Sep 2020)
"
In a tasting of 20-plus wines from The Wine Society that included, among others, an excellent Brézème rouge, Barolo, Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir (the two latter in the Exhibition range) and Shaw & Smith Adelaide Hills Shiraz, I wasn't expecting to be bowled over by the £7.50 Chilean Cabernet Sauvignon. But I was. Yes, bowled over. I'm not remotely suggesting it's on a par with those other four other reds (variously priced between £16 and £26), but for sheer value this is very hard to beat, especially as you could cellar it for a couple of years.
The nose takes you straight into a core of deep, ripe, crunchy blackcurrant fruit, suffused with cedary spice, smoky chocolate oak and earthy minerals, and the palate supports it with pebble-smooth, firm tannins and a streak of herbal freshness. The excellent 2018 vintage has done its bit, but all credit to the Society's buyer for Chile, Toby Morrhall, and the giant Concha Y Toro who produced it, including ageing it in French oak barrels. All in all, an inviting, powerful wine with more intensity and class than we have a right to expect at this price.
Now for food: perfect for braised lamb shanks, rich stews (meat or vegetarian), including with a bit of chilli, winter roasts, proper bolognese ragù, or aged hard cheese. - Joanna Simon
"
JancisRobinson.com (12th Aug 2020)
"
Deep smudgy crimson. Rather smart and slightly
unexpected smoky reductive note at first, then plenty of blackcurrant fruit
under that with the freshness of blackcurrant leaf but without any greenness.
I'd suggest decanting or jugging this to give it a bit more air. Chewy and creamy
at the same time, a terrific depth of dark fruit and a hint of chocolate to
the smooth but present tannins. VGV and should age well for a ridiculously
good inexpensive wine. 16/20
Julia Harding MW
"
decanter.com (30th Jul 2020)
"Buyer Toby Morrhall
reckons this is the best Chilean cabernet for the Society's label that he
has ever sourced, and it is an absolute bargain for the quality, from the
excellent 2018 vintage. Made by Concha y Toro, it's powerful stuff, bursting
from the glass with aromas of blackcurrants, damson and lead pencil notes. The
well-extracted palate offers more inky purple fruit, along with exotic
sandalwood and menthol oak notes, raspy tannins and a hint of dried mango on
the finish. Delicious now but hold a few bottles back for when it gains more
savoury maturity. 91/100 Tina Gellie"
2017 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"Good with lamb chops and better with the cheese that followed. Still a little firm and would have benefited from opening earlier and decanting. Will buy again."
Mr Trefor Rosser-James (17-Jul-2019)
"Very disppointing wine. Left a bitter after taste and would not want to buy or drink again."
Mr Michael Berry (24-Apr-2019)
"We thought this very dull and unrefined. Many better ones out there "
Mrs Jane Barry (21-Apr-2019)
"Tasty full bodied. Descriptions was accurate. Quite acidic. Wasnt blow away but Would buy again, hence the 4*"
Mr Ajay Sabnis (04-Apr-2019)
"Serviceable drinkable but not outstanding buy again as a mid weeker"
Mr Owen Duffy (28-Mar-2019)
"BOOF …..an uncomplicated delivery of blackcurrant and power
An excellent benchmark and v good value for money, provides an excellent challenge to those wines asking a higher price
higher priced CBs will need to deliver on complexity"
Mr John Miller (04-Jan-2019)
"Whenever we roast lamb, this is the wine I reach for, a lovey match. I am amazed that it doesn't appear on 'food matches'.
The description is accurate, the price is attractive, what's not to like?
.
"
Mr Sidney Roots (22-Oct-2018)
"Great guidance on the description, and very reliable. Good stuff, popular with all in our house, will please all."
Mr William Tutton (27-Sep-2018)
"The description is bang on. A very good example of CB style. Good value at current price £6.95"
Dr Brian Murray (15-Aug-2018)
2017 VINTAGE - PRESS REVIEWS
Church Times (20th Dec 2019)
"… really ripe fruit
makes a wine that genuinely tastes of the grape variety from which it was made.
It is a perfect partner for rare roast beef. - Christopher Fielden"
2015 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"true to the information provided, complex flavours, think it a little too harsh for drinking without food, however a good cab sauv. "
Mr Martin Reeves (22-Jun-2018)
"4.00/5.00"
Mr Michal Slavik (10-Apr-2018)
"This is an excellent choice from the Society. Great value for money, and I would not hesitate to order again."
Mr Andrew McManus (09-Apr-2018)
"One of the more modestly priced wines, but punches well above its weight. Typical Cabernet earthiness and power, rounded, balanced and dense. A bit of spiciness and smooth tannins. I would recommend this wine."
Mr John Lay (07-Apr-2018)
"The 2014 was a stunner. This year isn't quite as good, but is still pretty impressive. Definitely Cab. Sauv., but with that distinctive Chilean nuance.
Very good value for money."
Mr Peter Nelson (09-Nov-2017)
"As it says on the label, 'power and elegance'. A notch up from the Concha y Toro wines in the supermarket (which are always good), though similar in price. Well done Wine Society for your 'collaboration' with the winemakers. A lovely glad to drink during the week."
Mr David N M Mitchell (10-Aug-2017)
Mr Alex Downham (14-Jun-2017)
2013 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"Finally got round to drinking this... amazed by the value. Really very, very good... highly recommended, wish I could buy more."
Mr John Stephenson (22-Sep-2017)
"Stonking. I feel guilty for paying so little for it - Gofd knows what the grower's are getting. Whatever it is, it isn't enough. This is a good wine at a fantastic price and represents tremendous value for money."
Mr John Carr (28-Jun-2017)
"Outstanding for the price!"
Mr Alexander Layzell-Payne (31-May-2017)
"This is one of my favourite wines in this price range. Highly recommend."
Mr Alexander Layzell-Payne (22-May-2017)
"Wow. Outstanding. A bottle of Vimto, stirred briefly with an unlit cigar, while standing next to a wood fire, drunk through a mouthful of marmalade after a quick diesel oil swill (not in a bad way). And all this for only £6.50!"
Mr Peter Nelson (02-Feb-2017)
"I give 4 stars to wines that I like and intend to come back for more. Enjoyed this very much. Great value."
Mr Chris Futcher (10-Jan-2017)
"Very different wine from the last time I drank this about 3 years ago, when it was what I would call a 'standard' Chilean Cab.Sauv. of above average quality.
When I opened this, my first impression (and probably second) was of a young southern French Syrah, with bouquet and palate of that rather than CS. I was very close to contacting WS to check that there hadn't been a 'rogue' labelling or bottling....however on the second day, some of the CS characteristics began to show, there was some restrained blackcurrant fruit. However, it was most definitely not in the very forward New World varietal style.
It's a good wine, but I would certainly recommend opening and decanting at least a couple of hours before drinking, to get the varietal character. I will try a second bottle before I come to a more definitive view, but some of the comments below don't quite ring true - but they may be from the previous vintage? The comment about unusual hidden flavours is quite accurate."
Mr Mark Colman (11-Nov-2016)
"I am no MW by any standard. What I know about wine could be printed, in capitals on the back of a postage stamp. But.... this is the wine I tend to pull out when anything beefy, or in any special way flavoursome is on the Boyce menu. I don't suppose it's really very clever, I really don't know, but when a good honest bottle of red, with a bit of body is required, this is the one. Wine of this standard, at this price, 2013, is as far as I'm concerned, a steal. Long live Chilean Cabernet Sauvignon. Please, just keep it coming."
Mr Julian Boyce (16-Aug-2016)
"Unusual hidden flavours, highly recommended."
Mr Martin Reeves (11-Aug-2016)
"This is my favourite, do-it-all, go to wine. I am no expert but, I have drunk some awful Tosh from other suppliers costing much more than this. I just keep coming back for more. There are others I like but, this, for me, is red wine."
Mr Julian Boyce (20-May-2016)
"I really enjoyed this wine. An initial fruit burst on the palate gave way to a pleasant finish. Will remember to order a few bottles later in the year to see me through winter. Excellent value"
Dr Brian Carr (15-May-2016)
"This is the same price as the Silbador but is in a different league altogether. Fruity, sweet but not too sweet, good tannins and a bit of mint. Really classy."
Mr Jason Mossman (03-Mar-2016)
2012 VINTAGE - MEMBER REVIEWS
"Full palate of cedar and blackcurrant. Sweet by just the right amount. Exceptional value even by wine society standards. You aren't going to find anything as good in supermarket for under a tenner, actually I wouldn't be disappointed if a paid £12+. Pure and faultless - sophisticated and delicious. I've probably tried over 100 Society bottles now and this stands out as being the best value."
Mr Anthony O'Halloran (08-Nov-2015)
"Just received a case of this at the reduced price of £66 which is good value for this cab sav. I still prefer The Society's Merlot but you can't go far wrong with this for the price."
Mr David Marshall (03-Aug-2015)
"I'm not normally a Cab drinker due to a number of bad and/or indifferent (albeit less expensive) ones in the past. So it was for this reason that this was one of my 12 bottle choices, along with another New World to see what a Society picked one would be like? So I was very pleasantly surprised by this one as it was a lovely easy to drink wine that had bags of berry flavour and a finish that just coated my whole mouth but at the same time not harsh in any way. This will go down on my “… buy more list”."
Mr John Devlin (10-Jul-2015)
"Had with roast chicken and veg. Opened about 2 hrs before. Really recommend it a lot. Very drinkable. Complimented the dinner very well."
Mr Tony Bedborough (10-May-2015)
"This is delicious - Great Cabernet flavours. This particular Society bottle is very good quality - affordable for the quaffable occasion with a group or to enjoy on your own. It's what I expected of The society and will buy again at this price."
Mr Paul Colenutt (05-May-2015)
"Cab sav full of fruit but not too tannic. A definite favourite with my good lady!"
Mr Steve Parker (21-Apr-2015)
"This was a bit of a revelation really. Bags of full flavour. Oakes with blackcurrant, cherry and good depth. Great value for money!"
Mr Steve Parker (06-Mar-2015)
"Smells of blackcurrant preserve with woody notes. Full bodied. Cedar-wood taste. High tannin gives a slightly bitter/dry finish. Wouldn't pay more than £5.50. Not bad but definitely not great."
Mr Gary McCormack (24-Feb-2015)
"A nice cab sav but not massively better than Casillero Del Diablo cab sav from the same producer which you can pick up for under £5. Not as good a buy as The Society's Merlot but still worth trying."
Mr David Marshall (22-Dec-2014)
"An absolute steal at this reduced price! Initially ordered two cases and have just ordered two more. A very well balanced wine with good integrated fruit and soft, yes soft tannins which give the merest tingle on the top gum. A long finish with vanilla oak to the fore a la Rioja , which I personally love - tastes more like 18 rather than 8 months in barrel."
Mr John A Tipping (23-Nov-2014)
"A huge disappointment. Harsh finish and full of tannin. Having just read some reviews from other members I can scarcely believe that they were drinking the same wine. It is OK with very spicy food but not with any delicate flavours or on its own. We will not buy it again."
Dr David Pitcher (18-Sep-2014)
"If you're expecting this to be a supermarket style fruit bomb, think again. It's much more restrained than that, and although it's still fruit forward it never comes close to tipping over the line into alcoholic fruit juice, and it's all the better for it. Another bargain from TWS."
Mr Kieran Hynes (30-Aug-2014)
"I tried this just a couple of weeks ago and thought what a wonderful wine and fantastic value. I made a mental note to order more next time. It's good to know I am not alone in thinking this is a bargain. It put me in mind of the Society Chilean Merlot a few years ago that was declared Champion of Champions."
Mr Antony E Langstone (28-May-2014)
"A good example of Cab Sauv with the classic CS taste. Well rounded and pleasing. Excellent with game amd red meat.
"
Mr Cliff Snelling (17-Mar-2014)
"Dark in colour and can really taste the oak, improved greatly after 30 mins decanting as other reviews have said. Very nice, I'm a real fan!"
Mr Craig Owen (18-Jan-2014)
"The first glass was a bit harsh and over oaked, so I left the bottle open for 24 hours. Now much better; not a Claret lookalike but oaky on a par with a Rioja and a very decent Red indeed, with nicely balanced fruit & gentle tannin. Label is awful, so kill two birds with one stone and decant early. Quite frankly its an excellent bottle for under £7.
"
Mr Tim Potts (29-Dec-2013)
"Needs to be opened a good hour before drinking to be at its best (or better still decanted). Great value and we really enjoyed this wine which you could be forgiven for thinking it is a much more expensive French Cab Sauv."
Mr Brian Kain (17-Aug-2013)
"If like me you often avoid Cabernet Sauvignon with the view that it is a food wine and quite high in tannin, think again with this one, as it's really smooth. Easily drinkable on it's own and I think it's great value."
Mr Richard Burton (31-Mar-2013)
"Bottle label notes state 'classic style'. My novice palate interpreted this as 'French', as it was more austere than a lot of Chilean fruit bombs I have tasted. Very good and excellent value for money. This was exactly what I hoped for when I joined the Society. I will definitely reorder and contemplate a blind taste against some left bank clarets (at probably at least twice the price of this one)."
Mr Stewart Cusworth (30-Jan-2013)
"Fantastic wine to come home to after a busy day at work, went well with our meal, looking forward to receiving some more, we've just ordered a case!"
Dr Paul M Bateson (15-Jan-2013)
"Not your average 'Cab'! This stands out from the ever so popular Cabernet Savignon. Soft, fruity & ultra smooth tannins. To say there are hints of vanilla & liquorice, I may well be putting people off! This is a great all rounder, with or without food. It is not too full bodied, definitely a medium & the alcohol content is well absorbed within the wine. Suberb value & well crafted :D"
Mr James Hibbert (10-Nov-2011)
"This is a fantastic Cabernet Sauvignon and for the price an absolute steal especially coming from the well regarded Concha y Toro. Black Fruit, Smooth with a hint of Tannic Structure, Long Finish. A crowd pleaser and our House Red! Good with or without food."
Mr Darren Jefford (23-Oct-2011)
"Great value for money. Ripe fruit, depth of body with smooth finish."
Mr Robert Beadman (20-Aug-2011)
"This was one of the first wines we have tried having only recently become Society members. Full and fruity and bursting with flavour it's absolutely delicious...now where's my credit card!"
Mr Phil Paterson-Fox (18-Jul-2011)
"We thought that this had a lovely bouquet and very deep velvet colour, but found that it did need some oxygenation. Even then, it was too cedary for us, and we struggled with it, as we found the ending a little harsh for us. Drinkable, and good as an everyday run-of-the-mill find, but we wouldn't buy again."
Dr Aref Dyer (27-May-2011)
"This is a benchmark Cabernet Sauvignon which has deservedly become a classic. It has excellent structure and length. Outstanding value for money and recommended without hesitation to other members who have not yet tasted it."
Bernard T Hawcroft Esq (10-Jun-2010)
"This wine backs up one of my obsessions: the variable quality control one finds everywhere. We bought a case - because it was so highly rated (by Stephen Spurrier recently and Toby Morrall more generally), because it was cheap (£5 under offer), because we've found it generally good in the past, because we think Chilean wines good value, because we should support Chilean wines at the moment (etc.). The first bottle was not in perfect condition - there was an initial acidity which smoothed out after 15-20 minutes; good but imperfect. The second was 'heavy' and charmless; drinkable but clearly not right. The third bottle was absolutely spot on - and clearly identifiable as such from the very first sniff. Very few wine writers acknowledge this problem - Jane MacQuitty is almost alone, but even her estimate of 1 in 12 bottles defective is way, way too low."
Mr John L Moles (19-Apr-2010)
"A great beautifully mellow wine in which the full flavour develops with time. We found the taste improved considerably when the wine had been in the glass for about 15-20 mins. It become considerably more palatable having been oxygenated. A definite buy and highly recommended."
Mr Michael Aldridge (21-Feb-2010)
"A distinctive, fresh and superbly flavoured wine. About as good value for money as you can get on wine."
Mr Peter J Baden (26-Dec-2009)
"I have been a fan of the Society's own range of Chilean wine for quite some time. I consider them to offer excellent value: good quality wine at an affordable price (important as we are pensioners!). The Merlot, Syrah, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay has given us much pleasure with the Sauvignon Blanc being my wife's favourite tipple. For some unknown reason, until recently, I had never ordered the Cabernet Sauvignon. I always read with much interest the views of the Society's buyers. In the recent 'Buyers' Favourites' leaflet Toby Morrhall sang the praises of the Cabernet Sauvignon Maipo and that was sufficient for me to get a few bottles to try. We were not disappointed! We immediately ordered a whole case.
On opening one is struck by the beautiful bouquet. Difficult to describe. A mixture of vanilla and perhaps cherries or blackcurrants. On tasting one experienced a certain roundness, smooth and balanced. Although 14% we have found it to be perfectly acceptable to drink both with and without food. - good all-rounder. Who knows - it might just become our red 'house wine'! Enjoy it!"
Mr William Burnett (12-Aug-2009)
"I have bought the Society's Chilean Cabernet Sauvignon, Maipo Valley on a regular basis for a number of years.
This quality mellow wine consistently gives us a smooth and rich full bodied flavour which is enjoyed by family and friends alike.
"
Mr Bruce Marshall (07-Aug-2009)
"We have been buying this wine for several years now and it is undoubtedly superb value for the money - it is our every day red wine of choice and we are never without some in the house . We were interested to read in the Society's March 2009 Review the description of the making of the wine . It explains why it is so good and in particular how carefully the oak effect is fine tuned - in our view overoaking is so often the ruination of many South American (and European) red wines."
Mr Timothy M Curtis (06-Aug-2009)
"This is our standard red of choice. It represents outstanding value for money and is consistently of a high quality. It has all the classic Cab Sauv qualities of summer fruit and berries and we've never had a duff bottle in the years that we have been ordering the wine. If you like warm, fruity and full red wine for the price of cheap supermarket plonk, you should definitely give the Society Maipo Valley Cabernet Sauvignon a try."
Mr Nadi Jahangiri (05-Aug-2009)
"An excellent inexpensive wine, good value for money. Always have a few bottles to hand."
George Jamieson Esq (05-Aug-2009)
"As someone who is not infrequently underwhelmed by wines recommended by the cognoscenti, I was delighted to find that the praise given to this wine by the Society's buyers was well deserved. I cannot remember drinking a red wine costing under £7 with such depth of flavour without having to endure less enjoyable tannins or acidity. Unsure whether others would share my delight, I put this wine against other more expensive wines into a recent blind tasting with friends. All but one of us (he placed it second) declared it as their favourite. Give it a try, but please leave some for me!"
Mr Malcolm C Hodgson (05-Aug-2009)
"This is a fine example of Cabernet Sauvignon and the Society has, once again, 'delivered the goods'.
It shows all the expected traits of the grape variety one would expect and provides great value for money.
If you like Cabernet, you must try this!"
Mr Alan West (05-Aug-2009)
2012 VINTAGE - PRESS REVIEWS
Decanter (5th Sep 2013)
"From what is
considered the traditional heartland for Chilean cabernet, this is a
co-production between The Wine Society and Concha y Toro. It has a perky nose
with red cherry and ripe blackcurrant tones, while what follows on in the mouth
is a pure, vibrant and elegant expression of the Maipo region and cabernet
grape. - 50 best South American wines under £20"
Decanter (5th Sep 2013)
"
From what is considered the traditional heartland
for Chilean cabernet, this is a co-production between The Wine Society and
Concha y Toro. It has a perky nose with red cherry and ripe blackcurrant
tones, while what follows on in the mouth is a pure, vibrant and elegant
expression of the Maipo region and cabernet grape.
"
Chichester Observer (7th Mar 2013)
"A sound, cencentrated red, full of rich blackcurrant flavours, without being in the least bit jammy. It was aged in oak barrels for around eight months, and hints of this are evident in this very drinkable wine. Recommended. - Peter Homer"